"Einstein måste ha varit fel"

15

Jag har ett minne om en kort bortkastad passage i en bok av en känd sci-fi-författare som talar om en FTL-enhet som uppfunnits av O'Malley (eller ett lika stereotypiskt irländskt namn). När han frågade hur han kom omkring Einsteins lagar, säger O'Malley något som "Einstein måste ha varit fel".

Inte mycket att fortsätta, jag vet. Några identifieringar?

Det var förmodligen minst en tjugo år gammal bok.

    
uppsättning DJClayworth 05.05.2011 23:15

4 svar

5

Kanske Skylark Series ?

Crane: Three hundred and fifty million miles [in twenty minutes]. Half-way out of the solar system. That means a constant acceleration of about one light.

Seaton: Nothing can go that fast, Mart. E Equals M C square.

Crane: Einstein's Theory is still a theory. This distance is an observed fact.

Seaton: And theories are modified to fit facts. Hokay.

    
svaret ges 05.05.2011 23:33
2

Låter mig som något som skulle sägas med titeln på Callahan's Crosstimes Saloon , av Spider Robinson.

    
svaret ges 06.05.2011 05:51
2
Böckerna: "Stenkanalen" och "Cassini-avdelningen" av Ken MacLeod har ett maskhål fäst vid någon form av nära C (eller faktiskt mycket större än C tror jag) sond. Ormhålet är känt som Malley Mile till ära för en fysiker som heter I. K. Malley, som har den andra av de två böckerna. Jag kommer inte ihåg det speciella citatet, men det kan ganska troligt vara där.

De nämnda böckerna är den andra och tredje brevet av Fall Revolution-sekvensen.

    
svaret ges 06.05.2011 20:05
2

Det här är ett långt skott, men du kanske tänker på den djärva passagen nedan:

Arcot and Wade were laughing, but not Robert Morey. With a sorrowful expression, he walked to the window and looked out at the hundreds of slim, graceful aircars that floated above the city.

"My friends," said Morey, almost tearfully, "I give you the great Dr. Arcot. These countless machines we see have come from one idea of his. Just an idea, mind you! And who worked it into mathematical form and made it calculable, and therefore useful? I did!

"And who worked out the math for the interplanetary ships? I did! Without me they would never have been built!" He turned dramatically, as though he were playing King Lear. "And what do I get for it?" He pointed an accusing finger at Arcot. "What do I get? He is called 'Earth's most brilliant physicist', and I, who did all the hard work, am referred to as 'his mathematical assistant'." He shook his head solemnly. "It's a hard world."

At the table, Wade frowned, then looked at the ceiling. "If you'd make your quotations more accurate, they'd be more trustworthy. The news said that Arcot was the 'System's most brilliant physicist', and that you were the 'brilliant mathematical assistant who showed great genius in developing the mathematics of Dr. Arcot's new theory'." Having delivered his speech, Wade began stoking his pipe.

Fuller tapped his fingers on the table. "Come on, you clowns, knock it off and tell me why you called a hard-working man away from his drafting table to come up to this play room of yours. What have you got up your sleeve this time?"

"Oh, that's too bad," said Arcot, leaning back comfortably in his chair. "We're sorry you're so busy. We were thinking of going out to see what Antares, Betelguese, or Polaris looked like at close range. And, if we don't get too bored, we might run over to the giant model nebula in Andromeda, or one of the others. Tough about your being busy; you might have helped us by designing the ship and earned your board and passage. Tough." Arcot looked at Fuller sadly.

Fuller's eyes narrowed. He knew Arcot was kidding, but he also knew how far Arcot would go when he was kidding—and this sounded like he meant it. Fuller said: "Look, teacher, a man named Einstein said that the velocity of light was tops over two hundred years ago, and nobody's come up with any counter evidence yet. Has the Lord instituted a new speed law?"

"Oh, no," said Wade, waving his pipe in a grand gesture of importance. "Arcot just decided he didn't like that law and made a new one himself."

"Now wait a minute!" said Fuller. "The velocity of light is a property of space!"

Arcot's bantering smile was gone. "Now you've got it, Fuller. The velocity of light, just as Einstein said, is a property of space. What happens if we change space?"

Det här är från Project Gutenberg etext av Ace Books edition av John W. Campbell roman Islands of Space i hans Arcot, Morey och Wade serien. Jag antar att Morey kunde vara din "O'Malley", även om Arcot var den främsta uppfinnaren av FTL-enheten och Morey bara hans "matematiska assistent". Men de säger inte exakt "Einstein hade fel" så det här är inte en mycket bra matchning till frågan. Som jag sa, ett långt skott. (Mitt första giss var Skylark of Space men det är redan taget.)

    
svaret ges 22.07.2015 19:31