Vad Asimovs berättelser hänvisas till i filmen "I, Robot"?

5

Jag, Robot , 2004-filmen, har flera hänvisningar till de ursprungliga berättelserna av Isaac Asimov. Medan ingen av dem är fullständiga eller sanna mot historien, existerar de.

Några exempel är:

  • Little Lost Robot - när Sonny går vilse med resten av NS-5-robotarna.
  • Den Evolutionary Conflict - där robotarna generaliserar den första lagen och tillåter lite smärta för att skydda mänsklighetens framtid

Finns det andra?

    
uppsättning Good Person 30.12.2017 21:51

1 svar

6

Det har varit länge sedan jag läste Asimovs verk, jag kan inte personligen länka till dig varje detalj eller idé till bokens motsvarighet, men Likheter med boken av Wikipedia Artikeln i den här filmen läser (fet text av mig) :

The final script retained some of Asimov's characters and ideas, though the ideas retained were heavily adapted and the plot of the film is not derived from Asimov's work.

The characters of Dr. Susan Calvin, Dr. Alfred Lanning, and Lawrence Robertson resemble their counterparts in the source material only marginally. For example, in Asimov's work Dr. Calvin is middle aged by the time robots even begin to be widely used and recommends the destruction of over sixty robots when it is discovered that one amongst them is not bound by the first law of robotics. In the film, Calvin is an attractive young woman with a strong faith in the laws of robotics who reacts emotionally when robots are shot or destroyed.

Sonny's attempt to hide in a sea of identical robots is loosely based on a similar scene in "Little Lost Robot". The robot-model designation "NS" was taken from the same story. Sonny's dreams and the final scene resemble similar images in "Robot Dreams", and V.I.K.I.'s motivation is an extrapolation of the Three Laws that Asimov explored in "The Evitable Conflict", "Robots and Empire", "Foundation and Earth" and "... That Thou Art Mindful of Him", as well as several other stories.

The premise of robots turning on their creators—originating in Karel Čapek's play R.U.R., and perpetuated in subsequent robot books and films—appears nowhere in Asimov's writings. In fact, Asimov stated explicitly, in interviews and in introductions to published collections of his robot stories, that he entered the genre to protest what he called the Frankenstein complex—the tendency in popular culture to portray robots as menacing. His story lines often involved roboticists and robot characters battling societal anti-robot prejudices.

    
svaret ges 30.12.2017 22:12