Utställningen, en klockan 11:30 från 1964 till 1983, var värd Bill "Chilly Billy" Cardille och presenterade två skräckfilmer och / eller science fictionfilmer med varierande scariness och schlockiness kvoter. Cardille skulle introducera filmerna som sig själv och återkomma senare i pre- och post-kommersiella segment som spelar olika "skrämmande" tecken.
Enligt Flaherty:
“Whenever I did Monster Chiller Horror Theater, I tried to get a Pittsburgh reference in there ... The movies he showed were not scary. You had to really suffer through those things, they were so bad. There would be long periods of boredom, and then Chilly Billy would come back on, and that was entertaining.” Pittsburgh Post-Gazzette