Vad är betydelsen av båtturerna? [duplicera]

5

I Harry Potter och Trollkarlens sten ser vi Harry och resten av första årens ridbåtar upp till Hogwarts när vi först introduceras.

Enligt wikia (betona min):

The Hogwarts boats are traditionally used to transport the first year students, accompanied by Hogwarts gamekeeper Hagrid across the Black Lake from Hogsmeade Station to the castle at the start of the school year. At the end of the school year, first years take the boats back across the lake to Hogsmeade Station.

During the Hogwarts graduation ceremony, the seventh-years ride the boats back across the lake as they leave the school for the last time.

Så Harry och Co skulle ta en tur både till och från Hogwarts i början och slutet av deras första år, och examensklassen får en sista gång också innan de lämnar.

Vad är betydelsen eller betydelsen av dessa båtturer? Vem startade denna tradition och varför?

    
uppsättning DCOPTimDowd 05.07.2017 21:22

2 svar

6

Det är tydligt symboliskt. JKR säger inte vad det är symboliskt för, annat än att beteckna generell symbolism.

JN: You know, what I'm curious about now. What I think is one of the neatest things about the Hogwarts tradition is the entrance ceremony, from the whole riding the boats to the castle to the Sorting ceremony. What kind of traditions is there for graduation and leaving Hogwarts?

JKR: D'you know, John, I'm really glad you asked that, because I felt a huge sadness that I wouldn't write a graduation scene. You know, I really did. I knew-- I mean, I knew from early days that we would never see them graduate. I knew that he would-- well not he, they, all three of them, would not. We would not see them at school during what would've been their final year of education. But I really, during the final book, I kept thinking it would've been-- I felt sad that the book wasn't gonna end with that Feast scene, the graduation scene. But it couldn't, you know, it just couldn't. That's not the way it could've ended. It would've felt far too trite and-- you know, a lot of people felt the Epilogue was too sentimental, I think to have a graduation scene on top of what just happened would've been an absurd bit of anti-climax.

JN: Did you have ideas for what kind of traditions that they would do? Like ride the boats back out of Hogwarts, obviously, I think it's the cutest thing...

JKR: Oh yeah, definitely. No, I think the boats would've been the most poetic and beautiful way to get-- for them to leave. And symbolic in that they-- Harry wouldn't have seen the thestrals again, you know what I mean? It would've been a return to innocence, really. And passage over water is so symbolic, you know, in the history of magic, so, yeah. That would've been great.

PotterCast Interviews J.K. Rowling, part one.

    
svaret ges 05.07.2017 21:26
1

Jag tror att det är att indikera en övergångsperiod eller förändring som skulle förklara varför de lämnar det sättet när de examinerar. Det skulle hjälpa till att visa att de kom in eller lämnade en ny del av sitt liv. Jag hittade samma fråga på en annan sida som har liknande svar. länk

    
svaret ges 05.07.2017 21:29